77 Burger, Lower Manhattan, New York

Well done, in more ways than one

Burger source

I was on the way to the Staten Island Ferry with the family – the view of the Statue of Liberty and, apparently, a trip to the mall were on the agenda – and wanted lunch en route. The criteria were simple: good reviews, somewhere to sit, and no detour. 77 Burger on Pearl Street ticked all three. This was very much a neighbourhood burger place, so set your expectations accordingly, sort of the US equivalent of a pub burger, I guess.

The order

A bacon cheeseburger – as y’all know, this is my normal paradigm for a burger – with fries included. There’s a choice of cheese and I went for American – in keeping with the tradition, and enjoying, as I do, the gooey meltiness that only ultra processed cheese can deliver. Doneness is also offered, which is a rare (sic) thing, so I asked for medium. You order at the counter, the food was ready in about 15 minutes, and there was no queue to speak of at lunchtime. Sauces are self-serve – mustard, mayo, ketchup and chipotle – allowing maximum flex, and maximum homestyling with your burger or hot dog selection (that makes up the majority of the menu, though grilled chicken I think was also on offer).

The meat of it

Let’s take a look. The box arrived open and looked just as it does in the photo – decent. The top bun sits off to one side with its lettuce, a perfect round of red onion and a thick slice of a large tomato – not so much cheffy presentation as practicality, to allow for aforementioned self-saucing. The bottom half is heaped with thin, ruffled bacon on melted orange American cheese, and a modest pile of fries sits alongside.

Closed up, it’s a glossy, domed bun over lettuce, bacon and cheese, with the fries piled up in front.

In cross section there’s a thick 8oz patty, grey-brown all the way through – decidedly not the medium I asked for, and the kids – who asked for well done – got exactly the same. Homestyle, I guess.

First bite… let’s take it bit by bit. The meat – good quality, smoky, juicy, with a lovely grill sear, BUT slightly under-seasoned, dense and overcooked. I guess it needs to hold together for grill cooking but even so… The cheese and bacon – melty American, and crisp, thin American rashers – did the work of making up any missing umami. The bun – brioche with a light sweetness that would have been a good contrast to the umami elsewhere – was untoasted. Net result – it lent stodge and little else, just a slightly unnecessarily stiff, bready texture. The red onion and lettuce brought a bright freshness, but again as regular readers know – I don’t believe in tomato in a burger, particularly – so I ate it separately. The sauces – I helped myself to mustard, mayo, ketchup (leaving the chipotle on offer for another day) – and they all worked well together.

Now, onto the fries. These were medium-cut, skin on and golden, with a few darker edges – and they were amazing. They seemed at least double-fried, or from a part-fried frozen batch, and were crisp on the outside and squidgy in the middle, and perfectly seasoned. Could eat these all day.

Overall, the experience was a good one, despite the constraints of the subgenre. It’s a neighbourhood, homestyle burger (have I mentioned that?) rather than a gourmet one, and still a joy to share with the family. Toast the bun, cook it as asked and season the patty a bit more and it would be [chef’s kiss].

Monkey finger rating

  • Bun – 3/5. Untoasted, so more stodge than contrast.
  • Build – 4/5. Decent assembly.
  • Burger – 3.5/5. Smoky, juicy, lovely sear, but slightly too densely packed, under-seasoned and overcooked.
  • Taste – 4/5. Bacon, cheese and the self-applied sauces made up for the light seasoning.
  • Sides – 5/5. Crisp outside, squidgy inside and properly good.
  • Value – 4.5/5. Cheap for New York at US$16.99 with fries.
  • Burger rating – 4/5. A great neighbourhood burger, if not a notable gourmet one.

The deets

77 Burger – 77 Pearl Street, New York, NY 10004

A little over five minutes’ walk from the Staten Island Ferry terminal. Order at the counter.

Foxden, Jerdan Place, Fulham SW6

High performing, meaty burgers with excellent sides 

Burger source 

A friend said that someone had told him that Foxden was the second best burger in London, after Bleecker. Given that I really rate Bleecker, this was high praise and reason enough to trek out to West London to meet him there.

A “British burger restaraunt… [that] specialises in showcasing the best of British produce… with a field to fork ethos…” may sound worthy, but it’s a pretty no-nonsense diner that had more Deliveroo drivers waiting to be served than diners on the Tuesday night we sallied forth.

And a chef with an injured arm meant someone else (possibly the owner?) was behind the grill…

The order 

We went a bit bananas. Buffalo wings to start (6 for £8), and Jimbo and I shared the bacon cheeseburger (£12 – treacle bacon, cheese, lettuce, gherkin and house sauce), and the eponymous Foxden burger (£14.50 – Beef Patty, Slow Braised Pulled Beef, Truffle Cheese Sauce, Rocket & Red Onion Jam). We split three different catgories of fried root vegetable – sweet potato fries, regular fries, and ‘rosti-fries’ – all between £4 and £5 each. It’s heartwarming to be asked, straight out, when ordering – if we wanted the burgers medium or well done.

Medium, obviously, we’re not philistines.

The meat of it 

The Foxden – on the left – is a good looking burger. Toasted, glossy bun, a hint of the fresh stuff, good proportions of beef, pulled beef, cheese sauce and onion jam. The bacon cheese burger is a little more modest – well formed, but slightly less elegant on the plate, and with a visibly smaller patty.

Let’s take a cross section (or two).

There is little to complain about in cross section. The burgers are beautifully cooked, and you can see the brilliant, coarse ground meat. The buns are sturdy but not heavy, glossy but not – I think – sweetened. The balance of toppings (and bottomings) in the stack is perfect.

To the taste: both burgers are made with high quality, possibly dry-aged meat. There’s the light funk of ageing to them, and a rich, strong, beefy flavour. Now, let’s split the review.

The bacon cheeseburger first. FIrst bite – soft, melty meat. Light freshness from the salad, faint sweetness and chew from the treacle bacon, and a light, unctuous hint of salt from the cheese. It’s good, but not perfect – a harder sear would have given more textural contrast, ditto a crisper bacon choice. The cheese is too subtle, something stronger would have compensated for the slightly underseasoned patty. But it’s marginal – this is a good burger.

The eponymous Foxden – is a really odd experience. I’m not really one for pulled meat on a burger – it adds softness to softness and the texture balance often feels off, to my palate, and that was true here. But it was a strange sensation – the dry-aged-style funk of the meat was compounded by the truffle cheese sauce (or maybe it was all the cheese sauce and the meat wasn’t aged at all, I don’t know) – making for a strong, rich, deep flavour that will not be to everyone’s taste. The pulled beef added more savoury bite than the burger patty, which was unexpected – I’m more accustomed to BBQ pulled pork and was expecting it to be sweet. I think, if you like this sort of thing, it was a very fine specimen. If – like me – you like texture, crunch, and slightly less richness in your burger – you may find this a bit overpowering.

Sides and sauce-wise…

  • The regular fries were great. Crisp, well-seasoned, fluffy, brilliant on their owned or dipped. A decent portion too.
  • The rosti-fries were over-sold. They are tater tots and/or tiny hash browns. There’s little rosti to them. But they are extremely crisp on the outside, extremely fluffy on the inside, and very heavily seasoned – garlic, onion salt, possibly, but definitely paprika – rich, crispy, fluffy, delicious. Bit maybe a bit heavy on the salt.
  • The buffalo wings were strong – crispy, rich, juicy, and slickly coated in that perfect Uncle Frank’s hot sauce/butter combo (pretty sure it was Frank’s).
  • The sweet potato fries – are about as good as sweet potato fries get, and not photographed.

With a beer each, it came to about £28 a head including a 10% tip – pricey, but not bad value for the spread.

Monkey finger rating  

Bun –  4/5
Build – 4/5 (docked for the slightly inspid build on the bacon cheeseburger 
Burger – 4/5 (I’d probably rate the Foxden a 3.5, the bacon cheeseburger a 4, but I’m feeling generous) 
Taste –  4/5 – an aggregate 4
Sides – 4.5/5 – really very good   
Value – 3.5/5 – a little steep.  

Burger rating – 4/5 – really a very solid choice, though not, as our tipster observed, as good as Bleecker. 

The deets 

Turn right out of Fulham Broadway shopping centre, and it’s about 4 minutes up the road. And/or a Deliveroo near you.

By crazy random happenstance, on my way home, I walked past what used to be the dilapidated street where my previous company’s office used to be, many years ago… to find it completely gentrified. Still, The Atlas lives. Huzzah!